Hotel on the Cay Restaurants Ranked (Best Food, Best Ambience, Best Value)
Trying to decide where to eat at Hotel on the Cay? This in-depth guide ranks the resort’s on-site dining and bar options by food, ambience, value, setting, and convenience—so you can confidently plan meals around your beach days, ferry schedule, and evenings on the cay. Whether you want Caribbean and international dishes at Harbormaster, a casual drink at The Beach Bar, or the best setting for al fresco dining by Christiansted Harbor, this breakdown shows what to expect and where the value is strongest.
Looking for the best restaurants at Hotel on the Cay? This guide covers your two main dining options on the island: Rolling Smoke for BBQ and casual island flavor, and Beach Bar for easy waterfront bites and drinks—so you can plan your meals during your stay on this unique St. Croix private island resort and know exactly what to expect.
At Hotel on the Cay, you have two dining venues: Rolling Smoke is your sit-down restaurant for BBQ, Caribbean-inspired meals, and full breakfasts, while Beach Bar is your casual waterfront spot for snacks, drinks, and easy island vibes between swims. Both venues create a relaxed, island-style dining experience that matches the private island setting.
Continue planning your stay at Hotel on the Cay with these quick guides. Explore room categories, learn about island activities and beach access, and discover what makes this unique St. Croix private island resort the perfect Caribbean escape for families and couples.
Hotel on the Cay Dining Options Compared
This table gives you the fastest breakdown of your two dining venues at Hotel on the Cay—what each spot offers, when to go, and who it's best for during your private island stay.
| Venue | Type | Best for | Best time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rolling Smoke | Full-service restaurant | Sit-down meals, BBQ dinners, full breakfasts, family dining | Breakfast, lunch, dinner |
| Beach Bar | Casual beach bar | Quick bites, drinks, waterfront relaxation, staying near the beach | All day (drinks + snacks) |
Venue-by-Venue Guide
Below is a practical breakdown of each dining spot at Hotel on the Cay—what the vibe feels like, what's on the menu, and how to fit each venue into your island vacation routine.
Rolling Smoke
Rolling Smoke is the main restaurant at Hotel on the Cay, serving BBQ-focused meals, Caribbean-inspired dishes, and full breakfasts. It's your go-to for sit-down dining on the island—whether you want a hearty breakfast before exploring St. Croix, a casual lunch between beach sessions, or a relaxed island dinner.
- Best for: families, sit-down meals, BBQ lovers, breakfast before excursions
- Menu highlights: smoked meats, Caribbean flavors, fresh island ingredients, full breakfast service
- Vibe: casual island dining, open-air or covered seating, relaxed and family-friendly
- Strategy: use Rolling Smoke for breakfast fuel before ferry trips or beach days, and dinner when you want a full meal without leaving the island
Beach Bar
Beach Bar is your casual waterfront spot for drinks, snacks, and quick bites throughout the day. It's perfect when you want to stay near the beach, grab a cold drink between swims, or enjoy an easy lunch without leaving the sand. The vibe is classic Caribbean beach bar—laid-back, open-air, and built for vacation mode.
- Best for: beach days, casual drinks, snacks between swims, staying near the water
- Menu highlights: tropical cocktails, beer, light bites, snacks
- Vibe: relaxed, waterfront, open-air, island casual
- Strategy: use Beach Bar for midday drinks and snacks so you don't have to leave the beach scene, then go to Rolling Smoke for a full dinner
Smart Dining Tips (How to Plan Your Meals)
- Start your day at Rolling Smoke: get a full breakfast before taking the ferry to explore Christiansted or heading out on island excursions.
- Use Beach Bar to stay in vacation mode: it's the easiest way to grab drinks and snacks without interrupting your beach time.
- Plan dinner at Rolling Smoke: it's your only sit-down dinner option on the island, so reserve time for a relaxed evening meal.
- Explore Christiansted dining too: since you're a quick ferry ride from downtown St. Croix, you can easily mix island meals with off-property restaurant nights.
- Ask about daily specials: Rolling Smoke often features fresh catches and seasonal Caribbean dishes that highlight local ingredients.
Use Rolling Smoke for breakfast and dinner, hit Beach Bar during the day for drinks and light bites, and plan 1–2 dinners in Christiansted if you want to explore more St. Croix dining options during your stay.
FAQ: Hotel on the Cay Dining
What restaurants are at Hotel on the Cay?
Hotel on the Cay has two dining venues: Rolling Smoke (the main restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a BBQ and Caribbean focus) and Beach Bar (a casual waterfront spot for drinks and snacks throughout the day).
Is there a dress code at Hotel on the Cay restaurants?
No formal dress code—both Rolling Smoke and Beach Bar are casual and island-friendly. Resort casual or beachwear is perfectly fine.
Do I need reservations at Rolling Smoke?
Reservations are typically not required, but it's a good idea to check with the front desk during peak travel times or if you have a large group.
Can I get drinks and food at the beach?
Yes—Beach Bar serves drinks and light bites throughout the day, so you can grab what you need without leaving the waterfront area.
Are there restaurants near Hotel on the Cay?
Yes—Hotel on the Cay is a short ferry ride from Christiansted, St. Croix, where you'll find a variety of local restaurants, cafes, and bars. You can easily explore downtown dining and return to the island for the night.
What kind of food is served at Rolling Smoke?
Rolling Smoke specializes in BBQ and Caribbean-inspired dishes, including smoked meats, fresh seafood, island flavors, and classic American comfort food. Breakfast includes full options like eggs, pancakes, and local favorites.
Is Hotel on the Cay all-inclusive?
No, Hotel on the Cay is not all-inclusive. Meals and drinks at Rolling Smoke and Beach Bar are available for purchase.
Can I bring my own food or drinks to Hotel on the Cay?
Yes, you can bring your own food and drinks to enjoy in your room or around the island. Many guests pack snacks, breakfast items, or beverages to supplement on-site dining.
BOOK YOUR STAY NOW
Questions? Contact Us!
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
More Hotel on the Cay Guides
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Hotel on the Cay: