Protestant Cay, Christiansted, St. Croix, 822, VI

WELCOME TO

Hotel on the Cay

Q: Who does Hotel on the Cay welcome as guests?

Hotel on the Cay is a 53-room island resort that welcomes couples, families with children of all ages, and adventure seekers . It is not an adults-only property, though children aged 17 and older are charged at the adult rate .

Q: How do guests get to Hotel on the Cay?

Hotel on the Cay sits on a private islet in Christiansted Harbor and is accessible only by boat . Registered guests use a complimentary ferry that runs about every 10 minutes from 7:00 AM to midnight, departing from the dock in front of the King Christian pickup point on the Christiansted boardwalk.

Q: What are the check-in and check-out times at Hotel on the Cay?

Check-in at Hotel on the Cay begins at 3:00 PM , and check-out is by 11:00 AM . A photo ID and credit card are required at check-in, and guests under 21 must check in with a parent or official guardian .

Q: Does Hotel on the Cay have a swimming pool?

Hotel on the Cay features an outdoor pool on-site; however, it is currently temporarily closed . Guests can still enjoy swimming directly off Cay Beach just steps from the property.

Q: What dining options are available at Hotel on the Cay?

On-site dining at Hotel on the Cay includes Harbormaster , serving international and Caribbean dishes with al fresco seating and a weekly all-you-can-eat beach barbecue, plus The Beach Bar , open daily from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM .

Private-Island Beach Hotel in Christiansted Harbor, St. Croix

Stay on a small private islet in Christiansted Harbor, reached by a short complimentary ferry from the historic waterfront. Enjoy soft white sand, calm turquoise water for swimming and snorkeling, private balconies with water views, free Wi-Fi, and easy access to Christiansted sights, boat tours, and water-sport rentals. With an on-site beach bar, barbecue grills, multilingual staff, and relaxed island views, this St. Croix hotel suits couples, families, and adventure seekers.

Guest room with two beds, dresser, mirror, TV, wicker chair, and balcony doors at Hotel on the Cay.

Guest room bed with red runner and sliding doors overlooking water and palms at Hotel on the Cay.

Guest room kitchenette counter with coffee maker, sink, microwave, cups, and towels at Hotel on the Cay.

Sliding doors open to a balcony with water, boats, palms, and hills at Hotel on the Cay.

Arched balcony view of palm trees, blue water, sailboats, and hills at Hotel on the Cay.

Guest room kitchen with wood cabinets, microwave, granite-look counter, and refrigerator at Hotel on the Cay.

Guest room kitchen with wood cabinets, stove, coffee maker, sink, and ceiling fan at Hotel on the Cay.

In-room bar counter with rattan stools and microwave at Hotel on the Cay.

A guest room kitchenette with white cabinets and small appliances at Hotel on the Cay.

Rattan sofa, armchairs, and glass tables in a sitting area at Hotel on the Cay.

Living room with wicker seating, arched windows, and pale green walls at Hotel on the Cay.

Suite living area with wicker chairs, kitchen, refrigerator, and bedroom doorway at Hotel on the Cay.

Bathroom vanity, toilet, towels, and shower curtain at Hotel on the Cay.

Bathroom toilet beside a shower curtain and wooden louvered door at Hotel on the Cay.

Bathroom sink with wall-mounted hair dryer and mirror at Hotel on the Cay.

Shower dispensers and soap dish in a tiled bathroom at Hotel on the Cay.

Hotel on the Cay beachfront is seen from the water with palms and clouds overhead.

Palm trees, sandy shore, docked boats, and harbor buildings at Hotel on the Cay.

Sandy beach with a thatched umbrella, palms and boats offshore at Hotel on the Cay.

Beach with thatched shade, harbor boats and hillside town views at Hotel on the Cay.

Striped beach umbrella framing harbor, hills and waterfront buildings at Hotel on the Cay.

Beach umbrella, palm tree and harbor-facing buildings across the water at Hotel on the Cay.

Palm trees on the white sand beach at Hotel on the Cay with boats offshore.

Arched guestroom building beside the water and gardens at Hotel on the Cay.

Tropical courtyard walkway between arched hotel buildings at Hotel on the Cay.

Sunlit harbor view with palm trees, beach, and sailboats at Hotel on the Cay.

View from the water toward the beach and palm-lined shore at Hotel on the Cay.

Dramatic cloudy sky over the water and palms at Hotel on the Cay.

Iguana on the sandy beach near a tropical drink at Hotel on the Cay.

Elevated view of palms, beach, harbor, and hills from Hotel on the Cay.

WHAT'S INCLUDED IN YOUR STAY

ALL-INCLUSIVE

Dining & Drinks

Enjoy access to the on-site Beach Bar and Rolling Smoke, with barbecue grills also available for relaxed island meals.

Room Basics

Rooms include kitchenettes with refrigerator, microwave, toaster, and coffee pot, while room service and stocked mini-bars are not listed.

Beach Service

Beach towels are provided, while loungers, umbrellas, and cabanas are available to rent at posted Dockhouse rates.

Island Entertainment

Enjoy the beach setting, garden, terrace, nearby boat tours, and Christiansted waterfront access by complimentary guest ferry.

Water Sports

Arrange nearby snorkeling, kayaking, windsurfing, sailing, scuba diving, surfing, parasailing, fishing, and personal watercraft activities from the Christiansted area.

Free Wi-Fi

Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property, helping guests stay connected from rooms and common areas.

Discover top Accommodations

Rooms & Suites

Explore All Accommodations

Deluxe Room balcony facing harbor water and hills at Hotel on the Cay.

Harbormaster Room

290 ft²
4 Guests
1 King Bed

SAVOR THE FLAVOR

reSTAURANTS & BARS

Rolling Smoke

BBQ Restaurant

A smoky BBQ restaurant at Hotel on the Cay serving barbecue favorites in an easy island setting. Rolling Smoke is perfect for guests craving hearty, casual flavors by the water, with a relaxed feel that fits a laid-back day on the cay.

Beach Bar

A casual beach bar at Hotel on the Cay offering Caribbean cocktails by the sand and turquoise water of Christiansted Harbor. The Beach Bar is perfect for laid-back drinks after a swim or ferry ride, with an easy island feel.

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

hotel location

Explore The Area

Set along the calm shores of Cay Beach in historic Christiansted, Hotel on the Cay offers an all-ages escape surrounded by natural beauty and world-class snorkeling. The resort sits on Protestant Cay, reached by a short complimentary ferry from the Christiansted boardwalk, with turquoise water perfect for swimming just steps from the sand. Nearby, guests can explore Fort Christiansvaern, an 18th-century Danish fort with harbor views, or venture to Buck Island Reef National Monument, a protected marine park just five miles offshore where hawksbill and green sea turtles nest on Turtle Beach. Day trips to the Cruzan Rum Distillery and horseback rides past sugar plantation ruins with Equus Rides offer culture and adventure within easy reach. Conveniently located about six miles from Henry E. Rohlsen Airport (STX), this resort blends secluded luxury with access to Christiansted’s top attractions.

What's Nearby

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

HOTEL ON THE CAY FAQs

Who does Hotel on the Cay welcome as guests?

Hotel on the Cay is a 53-room island resort that welcomes couples, families with children of all ages, and adventure seekers. It is not an adults-only property, though children aged 17 and older are charged at the adult rate.

How do guests get to Hotel on the Cay?

Hotel on the Cay sits on a private islet in Christiansted Harbor and is accessible only by boat. Registered guests use a complimentary ferry that runs about every 10 minutes from 7:00 AM to midnight, departing from the dock in front of the King Christian pickup point on the Christiansted boardwalk.

What are the check-in and check-out times at Hotel on the Cay?

Check-in at Hotel on the Cay begins at 3:00 PM, and check-out is by 11:00 AM. A photo ID and credit card are required at check-in, and guests under 21 must check in with a parent or official guardian.

Does Hotel on the Cay have a swimming pool?

Hotel on the Cay features an outdoor pool on-site; however, it is currently temporarily closed. Guests can still enjoy swimming directly off Cay Beach just steps from the property.

What dining options are available at Hotel on the Cay?

On-site dining at Hotel on the Cay includes Harbormaster, serving international and Caribbean dishes with al fresco seating and a weekly all-you-can-eat beach barbecue, plus The Beach Bar, open daily from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM.

What activities and amenities does Hotel on the Cay offer?

Hotel on the Cay offers free WiFi, a garden and terrace, and easy access to snorkeling, kayaking, windsurfing, sailing, and wave runner tours. Beach loungers, umbrellas, and cabanas are available for rent at the Dockhouse.

Does Hotel on the Cay allow pets?

Hotel on the Cay does not allow pets, so guests should plan accordingly when traveling to the island property.

Is parking available at Hotel on the Cay?

Hotel on the Cay offers self parking on-site for a surcharge, and some listings note free public parking may be available nearby with no reservation required.

Can I host a wedding at Hotel on the Cay?

Hotel on the Cay is a popular setting for private-island wedding ceremonies, with couples exchanging vows surrounded by turquoise water and palm trees. Interested guests are encouraged to contact the wedding team directly for planning details.

Is Hotel on the Cay undergoing any renovations?

Hotel on the Cay has renovation work scheduled from May 2026 through December 2027, with the completion date subject to change as improvements continue across the property.

Hotel on the Cay

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!